De Bello Gallico: Liber Primus - Forum Book Club

By Decimvs, in 'De Bello Gallico', May 18, 2010.

  1. Bitmap Civis Illustris

    Location:
    Cygnea, Gena
    the answer is simple: because dies is feminine here. dies can be of either gender. In prose, it usually means something like "appointment" if it is feminine; in poetry the genders are usually completely interchangable.

    that would leave quam ob rem stranded
  2. Tactixian New Member

    Oh, cool. That makes it very clear, thanks.
    Cum civitas ob eam rem incitata armis ius suum exequi conaretur

    When the state, incited to arms on account of this matter, endeavored to follow its law

    Does that leave Cum ob rem any more stranded than the Perseus Project version?
  3. Bitmap Civis Illustris

    Location:
    Cygnea, Gena
    cum ob rem?? oO
  4. Tactixian New Member

    Well the phrase is cum civitas ob eam rem. What is being stranded by my translation? I don't see a quam ob rem.
  5. Bitmap Civis Illustris

    Location:
    Cygnea, Gena
    oh, sorry ... meant to say ob eam rem ... it goes with incitata
  6. Imber Ranae Ranunculus Iracundus

    In addition to what Bitmap has said, "to arms" would be ad arma, not armīs. Ablative of means is the only possibility here, I think.
  7. Nooj Civis Illustris

    Location:
    Sydney, Australia
    I guess reditio has the force of gerund or verbal noun and takes a direct object here? Interesting.
  8. Bitmap Civis Illustris

    Location:
    Cygnea, Gena
    That's fascinating, indeed ... but it's not entirely unusual for verbal nouns to retain some of their verbal character; especially nouns that are formed on the basis of verbs of movement. You often find those kinds of nouns linked with adverbial expressions (e.g. prepositions: aditus ad urbem), too. I think reditio domum belongs into that category.
  9. Decimvs Aedilis

    Translation for Chapter 5 (Taken from The Perseus Project)

    [5] After his death, the Helvetii nevertheless attempt to do that which they had resolved on, namely, to go forth from their territories. When they thought that they were at length prepared for this undertaking, they set fire to all their towns, in number about twelve-to their villages about four hundred-and to the private dwellings that remained; they burn up all the corn, except what they intend to carry with them; that after destroying the hope of a return home, they might be the more ready for undergoing all dangers. They order every one to carry forth from home for himself provisions for three months, ready ground. They persuade the Rauraci, and the Tulingi, and the Latobrigi, their neighbors, to adopt the same plan, and after burning down their towns and villages, to set out with them: and they admit to their party and unite to themselves as confederates the Boii, who had dwelt on the other side of the Rhine , and had crossed over into the Norican territory, and assaulted Noreia.

    C. Julius Caesar. Caesar's Gallic War. Translator. W. A. McDevitte. Translator. W. S. Bohn. 1st Edition. New York. Harper & Brothers. 1869. Harper's New Classical Library.

    Chapter 6 (Taken from The Latin Library)

    [6] Erant omnino itinera duo, quibus itineribus domo exire possent: unum per Sequanos, angustum et difficile, inter montem Iuram et flumen Rhodanum, vix qua singuli carri ducerentur, mons autem altissimus impendebat, ut facile perpauci prohibere possent; alterum per provinciam nostram, multo facilius atque expeditius, propterea quod inter fines Helvetiorum et Allobrogum, qui nuper pacati erant, Rhodanus fluit isque non nullis locis vado transitur. Extremum oppidum Allobrogum est proximumque Helvetiorum finibus Genava. Ex eo oppido pons ad Helvetios pertinet. Allobrogibus sese vel persuasuros, quod nondum bono animo in populum Romanum viderentur, existimabant vel vi coacturos ut per suos fines eos ire paterentur. Omnibus rebus ad profectionem comparatis diem dicunt, qua die ad ripam Rhodani omnes conveniant. Is dies erat a. d. V. Kal. Apr. L. Pisone, A. Gabinio consulibus.

    No Dictionaries Version

    Map of Roman Gaul

    Thank you to all those who participate in this discussion of De Bello Gallico: Liber Primus!
  10. Decimvs Aedilis

    I am hoping that this thread does not completely die. :)

    I have not been able to be as active in it as I had wanted; the summer has been very busy for me personally and academically. I am going to make more of an effort to post here, however.

    Thank you to those of you who have been active in this thread, and have kept the discussion and questions coming. :)
  11. Reziac Member

    I'm enjoying it too, even tho I've not had time lately to do more than read the translations -- at the very least it's getting me to read something that I might never have gotten around to without this forum. So yes, let's keep going, even if there aren't many comments on the work itself!
  12. Nikolaos schmikolaos

    To be completely honest, this thread is getting too confusing for me to follow. Maybe we should have a new thread for different chunks of text?
  13. Akela viam inveniam

    Location:
    Vancouver
    This is not a bad idea, especially since we have a whole subforum for the Latin readings now.

    The final decision is Decimvs', however :)
  14. Reziac Member

    Maybe one thread for the reading and the translation, and another (linked from the first) for each discussion? Tho I'm not sure that's really any less confusing :)
  15. Decimvs Aedilis

    Hmmmmm....... :wondering:

    *thinking*
  16. Decimvs Aedilis

    This is the direction that I am leaning. Is this ok with everyone else?

    I will create one thread with the readings and translations for chapters 1-20, and at the bottom of each chapter post, link to a thread for discussion of that chapter?
  17. Reziac Member

    I think it's worth a try. After all, if we wind up not liking the new format, we can always go back to this one! But it would certainly be more organised for folks who come in late and are trying to figure out just which chunk people are talking about.
  18. Nikolaos schmikolaos

    Sounds good to me.
  19. Decimvs Aedilis

    Sorry that this has taken so long. I am going to start chopping up this thread and making new ones very soon.

    We will do readings from De Bello Gallico Liber Primus, and there will be a thread for each chapter (or maybe for every 2-3 so that the Reading Forum does not appear overrun with Caesar threads) - Latin text and translations (the usual) as the first post, and then discussion of that chapter below.
  20. Reziac Member

    Cool by me.. I've been busy myself, and whenever you get to it will be absolutely fine!

Share This Page

 

Our Latin forum is a community for discussion of all topics relating to Latin language, ancient and medieval world.

Latin Boards on this Forum:

English to Latin, Latin to English translation, general Latin language, Latin grammar, Latine loquere, ancient and medieval world links.