I don't think I would lose ground if I learned lists* (and I did it a little in the beginning, that is when I was following a Latin course but didn't read real Latin on my own yet), and maybe if I did I would memorize even faster, possible, I don't know; but I just find it more pleasant to learn words little by little while reading; and even if I must look up a same word several times, I progressively memorize the major part (that is words that come up relatively often in what I read - and less common ones if they strike me). I just don't feel like reading lists, I prefer reading texts; and as it works, why bother my lazy self with something else... But yes, as you say, I suppose some methods will work better for some people, others for others (even if after all, there are not so many different methods, there would just be some "personal preferences" for one of the main ones). (And thank you for such comments about me...)
*Edit: Providing that learning lists would be in addition to all my reading, and not to replace part of it of course - to spend hours that I would have spent really reading, reading or writing down lists instead, would maybe make me lose a little ground - or rather progress slowlier, "lose ground" might be an overstatement. But on the other hand, if I did like you said, Socratidion, writing down words I encounter along with their definitions while I am reading, and making a quick review of those lists now and then, just having a look at them when I'm there doing nothing and see the sheets on my desk, maybe it would help me memorizing faster (but I don't really feel the need to, I'm happy as it is. I prefer it to be a little slowlier and agreeable, than a little faster and a little more boring...).
Edit 2: And anyway I'm learning by myself for my pleasure, it's not as if I were a student with vocabulary tests to pass; so when I don't understand or need to remember one meaning of a word, it's not that catastrophic; my dear dictionaries are always there to help me... And it progresses by itself with time and reading, at ease.
*Edit: Providing that learning lists would be in addition to all my reading, and not to replace part of it of course - to spend hours that I would have spent really reading, reading or writing down lists instead, would maybe make me lose a little ground - or rather progress slowlier, "lose ground" might be an overstatement. But on the other hand, if I did like you said, Socratidion, writing down words I encounter along with their definitions while I am reading, and making a quick review of those lists now and then, just having a look at them when I'm there doing nothing and see the sheets on my desk, maybe it would help me memorizing faster (but I don't really feel the need to, I'm happy as it is. I prefer it to be a little slowlier and agreeable, than a little faster and a little more boring...).
Edit 2: And anyway I'm learning by myself for my pleasure, it's not as if I were a student with vocabulary tests to pass; so when I don't understand or need to remember one meaning of a word, it's not that catastrophic; my dear dictionaries are always there to help me... And it progresses by itself with time and reading, at ease.